All-Ohio Valley Conference
2011-12
Raven Berry - Second Team
#Katie Hempen - All-Newcomer Team
Amanda Levens - Coach of the Year 

All-Great Lakes Valley Conference
2007-08
Amber Shelton - First Team

2006-07
Amber Shelton - First Team
Whitney Sykes - Second Team

2004-05
Julianne McMillen - HM

2002-03
Ruth Kipping - First team

2001-02
Ruth Kipping - Second team

2000-01
Misi Clark - First team

1999-00
*Misi Clark - First team
Sarah Cook - HM

1998-99
Kim Lowe - First team
Misi Clark - First team

1997-98
Kim Lowe - First team
#Misi Clark - First team
Alicia Harkins - HM

1996-97
Leslie Phillips - HM
Alicia Harkins - HM

1995-96
Terri Evans - First team
Alicia Harkins - HM

*Player of the Year
#Freshman of the Year