| SIUE All-Americans | |||
| Player | Position | Team | Year |
| Jack Blake | Forward | NA | 1970 |
| John Carenza | Forward | NA | 1970 |
| John Carenza | Forward | NA | 1971 |
| Vince Fassi | Back | Second | 1972 |
| Tom Galati | Back | Second | 1973 |
| John Stremlau | Back | Forward | 1973 |
| Chris Carenza | Forward | NA | 1974 |
| Bob Kessen | Midfield | NA | 1974 |
| Greg Makowski | Back | NA | 1975 |
| John Stremlau | Midfield | NA | 1975 |
| Greg Makowski | Back | NA | 1976 |
| Greg Makowski | Back | NA | 1977 |
| Mike Kelley | Midfield | NA | 1978 |
| Tom Groark | Back | First | 1981 |
| Ed Gettemeier | Goalkeeper | Third | 1982 |
| Chris Hundelt | Midfield | Third | 1983 |
| Bill Stallings | Forward | Third | 1984 |
| Steve Trittschuh | Back | Third | 1985 |
| Steve Trittschuh | Back | First | 1986 |
| Matt Little | Midfield | First | 1997 |
| Justin McMillian | Midfield | First | 2001 |
| Chris Camacho | Back | Third | 2002 |
| Addae Rique | Midfielder | First | 2003 |
| Cal Thomas | Forward | First | 2003 |
| Tim Velten | Back | Third | 2003 |
| Michael Burgund | Back | Second | 2004 |
| Mike Banner | Forward | First | 2005 |
| Kevin Thibodeau | Back | Second | 2005 |
| John Matthews | Midfield | Third | 2006 |
| Greg Crook | Goalie | Second | 2007 |
| Zach Bauer | Back | Third | 2007 |
| Randy Roy | Midfield | Second | 2007 |
| Dustin Attarian | Forward | Second | 2007 |
