- Ron Middleton vs. Nicholls State (1972), 9-inning game
(First-ever in NCAA-II Tournament)
- Jim Scheibal vs. Illinois Tech (1982), 7-inning game
- Mike McAfee, John Moad and Chris Kabbes vs. Savannah A&D
(1991), 5-inning game
- Tony Stoecklin vs. Northeast Missouri State (1991), 7-inning
game
- Jeff Johnson vs. Metro State (1991), 5-inning game
- Doug Fox vs. Southern Indiana (1995), 9-inning game
- Brian Matzenbacher vs. Kentucky Wesleyan (1999), 7-inning
game
- Brian Keating vs. Wisconsin-Parkside (2003), 7-inning game
- Adam Tallman vs. Concordia (N.Y.) (2005), 9-inning game
- Kyle Jones vs. Northern Kentucky (2006), 7-inning game
Note: Northeast Missouri State is now Truman State |
